| 18-04-2006 09:47 AM | ||
| Raasted |
In my opinion "Dune" (not dune2) should be both in adventure and strategy, since the game is 'divided' into 2: the first part which is adventure (fly around, meet people, talk to people, explore your palace) - the second part, where you command your legions of fremen top-down, harvest spice (as in Dune2) and so on is strategy. Definetly not just an adventure game.... /Raasted |
|
| 14-04-2006 03:13 AM | ||
| Eagle of Fire |
[quote]If you'd follow that logic than Dune 2, C&C and such would be Action games too, and they all involve Strategy. As a general rule, in Strategy you kill stuff by commanding stuff, while in Action you kill stuff by controlling your own character.[quote] I don't follow a logic, I only apply the correct genres. Games like Dune 2 or C&C are RTS, and the S in RTS mean Strategy. You don't need to kill stuff to have a strategy game, on the contrary. A strategy game is a game which require you to think about what you are doing in a strategic way, you don't really need to kill something to achieve that. |
|
| 14-04-2006 03:10 AM | ||
| guesst |
the one that got me started, Barbarian (Death Blade) I thought should be an action if Metal Mutant (also uses CGA) isn't in the crypt. I have to actually play some of the unsorted, but the first one, argh, looks action to me, but I'll check it out. But this is all my opinion, and this is not my web site, so meh. |
|
| 14-04-2006 02:23 AM | ||
| SupSuper |
Quote:
The Clue! and The Sting! (sequel of The Clue!) I'd consider Unsorted, since there's no specific category that covers them. You could consider them a mix of Action, Adventure, Strategy... |
|
| 14-04-2006 02:00 AM | ||
| Eagle of Fire |
Well, just looking in the strategy section since it's my favorite genre... Armor Alley should be in Action or Arcade. I have absolutly no idea why The Clue! is in the Strategy section... Netstorm is an action game. It has a lot of strategy involved, but it's definitly an action game. I have absolutly no idea what The Sting! is, but it's definitly not a strategy game. I never played Transarctica, but it sure looks like to me as an Adventure game with hints of strategy than the opposite. This is just a very quick overview. And I'd suggest that we open a new category named "Wargames". We have so much in the Strategy section that it can very easily stand as a genre, and I really think it polute the Strategy section since they are not really strategy games... |
|
| 13-04-2006 09:41 PM | ||
| BeefontheBone | Does Miss Classified/Unsorted Games get one of those sashes and a tiara? Can we see a picture? :P | |
| 13-04-2006 09:36 PM | ||
| Sebatianos |
Changing them is easy, it's hard to decide where to put them! Let's make a suggestion: Name the games that you (talking to everybody) think are misplaced and where do you (talking to everybody again) think we should put them! |
|
| 13-04-2006 08:46 PM | ||
| The Niles | Yes one of these days I am going to sort through all games on the site and place them where I want them. Some games are in he wrong category and even more are debatable. It is a hassle to change them now and those people who have the access are too busy to do it. | |
| 13-04-2006 06:19 PM | ||
| Sebatianos |
Well, generally updaters assign a game to a chategory. When it comes to the CRYPT it's very special. For a long time Kosta (the owner) didn't want CGA games to be added to the site. So THE CRYPT contains the game that priarily use CGA graphics (or TANDY). The Unsorted doesn't mean we couldn't put the games in a certain chategory, it's just that Pinballs don't really belong into action, it's bascially a simulation of the real machine, but I wouldn't put them there either. Yes, some games seem to be slightly misplaced (or could be in more chategories), but generally it's not so hard to find something. Which games did you have in mind? |
|
| 13-04-2006 04:52 PM | ||
| guesst |
I've found a few games that I've thought didn't belong where they were, or if they did some other games needed to be moved. In particular the Crypt has been this way for me. Plus there's alot of Unsorted that could easily be sorted. I've noticed Abandonia doesn't generally allow double categorizing, so I suppose sometimes it's a case of just choosing something when a game might fall into more than one category. Is there a set of rules that defines which category or another a game falls into? Who's in charge of deciding this stuff? |
|
