Privateer |
20-06-2006 12:10 AM |
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(Mighty Midget @ Jun 4 2006, 05:58 AM) [snapback]234169[/snapback]</div>
Quote:
<div class='quotetop'>QUOTE(laiocfar @ Jun 4 2006, 04:39 AM) [snapback]234165[/snapback]
|
Quote:
they arent random there is some random factor that make a combat to get an unexpected result like the RUGGED DEFENCE event when an unit with high entrenchment get their defence pumped up.
[/b]
|
Oh, I remember the RUGGED DEFENCE alright! Approaching a dug in infantry unit with anything other than artillery/planes/pioneers is suicide, I know. But I think I remember having all sorts of units slaughtered by this cursed factor after I dug'em up. A light tank (the HMG kind) should be able to cope with a dug-up unit out in the open. Not neccessarily so here, I'm afraid. Remember what tanks were designed for: During WW I they needed a weapon platform that allowed them to approach enemy HMG nests in the trenches. Enter the tank. In the latter part of WW II they evolved into a multi-role vehicle, to some degree acting as anti tank units. In Poland, the Polish cavalry units were mostly slaughtered by German tanks, though they occacionally took one out. In this game, the light German tanks, according to my memory, would do better mopping up the remains of damaged enemy units, and even then I was taken by supprise sometimes.
[/b][/quote]
A light tank coping with a dug up infantry? How? Remember, although infantry is represented by a single unit here, it doesn't mean that every soldier in that unit has just a rifle. Infantry units of that size would definitely have anti-tank teams (Bazooka for US or Panzershreik for German). Even earliest infantry had anti-tank grenades and mines. That's why they get a 1 or 2 in Heavy Attack: they CAN shoot back, just not very good at it. So if the attacking tanks are weak or caught in a bad position, they can and will be destroyed. If the infantry is heavily entrenched and built anti-tank defences, I can't imagine light tanks displacing them. In the open, it's another matter, and the game reflects that.
I've also done very well against cavalry with the earliest German tanks, so long as it is in the open. Of course, if the cavalry is entrenched in a city, it'd be suicidal to go there. WWII cavalry was basicly infantry anyway, they just used horses for quick mobility.
|