Kiddiarni

Is one of the big questions in philosophy

So what is the answer?

Is "I" the body or the Spirit? Or maybe both?

Here is an example that a philosopher made (don't remember his name)

"Mr.A and Mr. B are voluanteers in a test. They go into a machine and exchange "brains". So when Mr.A comes out he has the memories and thoughs, act and everything that is inside you (spiritual, not organic) of Mr. B and vice versa. So, is Mr. A still Mr. A or is He Mr.B now?"

When you have thought about that here's the next part.

"Mr. A has to choose a destiny for him when he comes out of the machine. The decision has to be COMPLETELY NOT-selfish. He has to say, which one will be tortured slowly and painfully to death, and which one of them will get one million dollars(Tax free :P). So if the decision has to be completely UN-selfish which one will get the million? Mr.A or Mr.B?"

Now, if you can reach a decision, all together, you have done something that philosophists haven't done, and probarbly never will.