it sounds like a good idea, and both good and bad points have been presented.
I think something that could be done would be likee, have different catergories each week.
One week, favorite Adventure, the next favorite action, and people can nominate anyone they want from that catergory.
Only thing that could be confusing, would be how votes are cast. They could be sent VIA PM for the first like, two or three days (Monday-Wednesday), followed by a thread created in which board members vote on the top five or ten or whatever out of those that received the majority of the votes via PM. Only problem with this, is you might not have a large majority, in which case the number of games each week in the top whatever would vary slightly.
If it was done something like this, I think it could work. The news could be something like those ads at the movies that say "Remember when:" and then list like, four movies from 1988 or something.
Yeah...it could work if it was done correctly, otherwise I think too many people would be disappointed by it.
|