I can fully agree with you and everything would make sence... but unfortunately LAW sometimes isn't fair nor does it always make sence.
It's the mater of what is WRONG/RIGHT against what is LEGAL/ILLEGAL.
Example:
You buy a TV.
A guy breaks in your house and steals the TV - no one can identify him.
You find a guy who's selling your own TV in his yard sale and take it (it's yours, you won't buy it back) - everybody sees you.
Who do you think will win at the court?
You only took your own thing back, but in the eyes of the LAW you're the criminal!
It's very much the same with P2P. Unfortunately the LAW in this case is so bad many people find nothing wrong with breaking it - and knowing they didn't do anything wrong.
|