I think we should make a semi-poll
Meaning that whomever launches the battle, will edit his or hers post with the votes for and against
What do you guys think?
That way it is easier to pick a winner in the end - although in the current one it is pretty easy. Holmes walks away with the victory even before Round 1 has commenced. Simply because Holmes would never allow himself to be trapped (unless that was part of his plan), and would've confronted Jigsaw while he was setting the whole thing up. Just to catch him in the act.
Holmes wins hands down.