I prefer the second version of the logo.
It's clearer and easier to read, it stands out more.
I personally think the 2005 logo is the best the site has had, and still surpasses the current logo, and the new proposed logo.
I'm not really sure why I like that logo, I guess it just feels simple and fun. Less contrived and artsy than the efforts since. I think the earlier designs show their age
It can be seen on the AB History page, here's the image:
I do think the 'proposed' logo is much nicer than the one we have at the moment. Coupled with a new site, I think it will grow on me. Good work
